Liability Determination for Accidents Caused by

Date:2026-11-19 14:47:24  Views:3

At around 15:00 on September 29, 2025, Lv did not park near Dongcheng Road in Longgang City, Wenzhou City, Zhejiang Province according to the parking space arrow, and the parking space was a limited time parking space. Lv's parking time was not within the limited time range. After parking the vehicle, Lv got off and went to a nearby shop, leaving Zheng in the car. Zheng opened the car door to get off when Lv was not in the car. However, he did not pay attention to the dynamics of the vehicle ahead and collided with the two wheeled electric vehicle driven by Gao, causing Gao to be injured and the vehicle to be damaged in a road traffic accident.


After the accident, Gao went to the hospital for treatment and was diagnosed with left radial head fracture, left radial collateral ligament fracture, etc. After identification, it was found that Gao missed work for 120 days, and the nursing and nutrition periods were both 60 days. Due to unsuccessful negotiations on compensation, Gao sued Lv and the insurance company that underwrites compulsory insurance to the court. During the trial, after the court explained the law and reasoning, Gao applied to add Zheng, the actual person who opened the door, as a co defendant.


After trial, the court believes that the first issue to be resolved in this case is the order of insurance compensation. According to Article 2 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Road Traffic Accident Damage Compensation Cases (II), which will officially come into effect on June 30, 2026, if a motor vehicle passenger causes damage to others while driving, and the infringed party claims that the passenger's liability belongs to the motor vehicle party and requests the insurer who underwrites compulsory traffic insurance to compensate within the liability limit, the people's court shall support it. The vehicle involved in this case was insured with compulsory traffic insurance by the insurance company, and the accident occurred during the effective period of the insurance. The insurance company also agreed to bear reasonable and legal losses within the insurance liability limit. Therefore, the insurance company should first compensate within the compulsory traffic insurance liability limit. If there is still a shortfall after insurance compensation, the compensation liability shall be borne in accordance with the provisions of the seventh part of the Civil Code on tort liability.


The court held that Lv, as the driver and actual controller of the vehicle, did not park the vehicle in accordance with the prescribed time and direction when parking the vehicle involved in the case, which constitutes illegal parking. As the first person responsible for vehicle safety, Lv had an obligation to ensure the safety of the vehicle after getting off the car. However, he failed to ensure the safety of the vehicle and did not fulfill his obligation to inform and remind the passengers on board, which had a causal relationship with the occurrence of the accident. Therefore, Lv should bear the main responsibility for the accident. As a passenger and the direct executor of the door opening behavior, Zheng has the obligation to observe the surrounding road conditions of the vehicle and not obstruct the passage of others. However, Zheng's negligence in observation and reckless opening of the car door directly led to the occurrence of this accident, and he should bear secondary responsibility for the accident.


It is worth noting that Lv and Zheng are friends, and Zheng is a free passenger. When the court divides responsibility, it takes into account the goodwill riding relationship between the two parties, but the act of "goodwill riding" does not mean that the driver can relax their safety management of the vehicle. The case was caused by the joint actions of the driver and the passenger, resulting in damages. Considering the degree of fault of both parties, the court determined at its discretion that Lv was responsible for 60% and Zheng was responsible for 40%.


After the first instance judgment of this case, all parties involved have complied with the judgment and withdrawn the lawsuit, and the defendant has fulfilled their corresponding compensation obligations.


The handling of road traffic accident disputes is related to the vital interests of the masses and the harmony and stability of society. The judgment in this case clarifies the compensation rules for situations where the passenger opens the door without compensation and causes damage to others. If the passenger of a motor vehicle drives the door and causes damage to others, the victim can sue the passenger, driver, and insurer together. The responsibility of the passenger belongs to the motor vehicle party, and the insurance company should first compensate within the insurance liability limit. If there are still deficiencies after insurance compensation, the liability ratio shall be determined based on the degree of fault of the driver and passenger. Taking a ride with good intentions does not mean that the driver can relax their safety management of the vehicle. The driver should still park the vehicle in a standardized manner, ensure the safety of the vehicle, and remind passengers to get off safely. Passengers should also pay attention to observation before opening the door to confirm that it does not obstruct others' passage and avoid "door opening killing" due to momentary negligence.


This article is transferred from the WeChat official account "Shandong Gaofa". Thank you!