Is the restaurant liable when a customer is injured from falling after excessive drinking?

Date:2026-11-12 09:21:43  Views:45

After dining and drinking, a customer fell and was injured while heading to the restroom. Should the restaurant be held liable? Recently, the Fangshan District People's Court in Beijing concluded a personal injury compensation case involving a fall after drinking. The court ruled that the restaurant, as the operator of a public venue, had fulfilled its safety obligations and should not bear compensation liability.


Li Mou was dining at a restaurant with friends. During the meal, he consumed excessive amounts of alcohol and became intoxicated. While heading to the restroom alone, he walked in the opposite direction and collapsed at the stairwell, striking the railing. Multiple staff members rushed to call Li's companions. Li was then assisted by his companions and went to the restroom again, where he fell once more. The incident resulted in facial lacerations and tooth fractures for Li, costing over 2,000 yuan in medical expenses.


Li argued that the floor in the restaurant's hallway was slippery at the time of the incident. After witnessing his fall, the staff only notified their colleagues but failed to take any other rescue measures. Additionally, the design of the restaurant's stair railings was flawed, with sharp edges that caused severe facial injuries. Li claimed the restaurant had not fulfilled its safety obligations and sued, demanding the court order the restaurant to compensate for medical expenses, lost wages, and mental distress damages, totaling over 30,000 yuan.


The restaurant argued that the hallway floor was clean, tidy, and free of debris at the time of the incident, with no slippery conditions. After Li fell for the first time, staff immediately called for his companion to assist him, who then helped him to the restroom. The restaurant had fulfilled its duty of safety assurance and rescue. The stair railing was installed for the convenience of consumers and did not have any design flaws or safety hazards. Li's injury was caused by his own excessive drinking, and the restaurant was not at fault and should not bear responsibility.


After deliberation, the court ruled that the key issue in the case was whether the restaurant had fulfilled its duty of safety assurance. Article 1198, Paragraph 1 of the Civil Code stipulates that operators, managers, or organizers of commercial venues such as hotels, shopping malls, banks, stations, airports, sports venues, and entertainment establishments who fail to fulfill their duty of safety assurance and cause harm to others shall bear tort liability. As an operator of a venue, the restaurant bears the responsibility to prevent harm to diners due to hazards in food service or facilities. Surveillance footage shows that the floor in the restaurant's hallway was free of debris and not slippery, with the incident occurring in a relatively spacious corridor. The stairwell was located on one side of the hallway, and the handrail causing Li's facial injury was installed to facilitate safe passage for descending users, with no design flaws. Upon Li's fall, the restaurant staff promptly called for his companions to assist, demonstrating timely response. Overall, the restaurant staff had fulfilled reasonable duty of care commensurate with their job responsibilities, and existing evidence is insufficient to prove a breach of safety assurance obligations. Li's fall and injury resulted from his own excessive alcohol consumption, and the loss should be borne by him.


In conclusion, the court ruled to dismiss Li's entire claim. Li was dissatisfied and filed an appeal. The appellate court upheld the original judgment.


This article is reprinted from the WeChat Official Account "Shandong High Court," and our gratitude is hereby expressed!